Mom’s 20-Year Mac and Cheese Recipe Still Can’t Decide If It Wants Oven or Stove

KEY POINTS

•Jennifer Messineo, after 20 years of cooking a signature mac and cheese recipe, tested it across three appliances in her kitchen for consistency.
•Using the same ingredients, she found the stovetop method made the creamiest sauce and held up best when reheated compared to oven or microwave methods.
•Although the oven method delivered the richest flavor and a crispy top, it required 35 minutes of cook time and cleanup, while the microwave version was the least creamy and underwhelming in taste.

Jennifer Messineo’s venerable mac and cheese recipe, marinated in family nostalgia for nearly two decades, faced its ultimate showdown: stovetop versus oven versus microwave. Armed with 8 ounces of sharp cheddar, 1.5 cups milk, medium pasta shells, and 2 tablespoons butter—all classically consistent for fairness—Jennifer tested the flavors like a cheese-obsessed Goldilocks. The stovetop produced the creamiest, most saucy mac, which even held up Fridays leftover better than your former relationship. The oven yielded the most lip-smacking, crispy-topped mac but demanded a 35-minute commitment and punitive dish-scrubbing duty. The microwave? Shockingly tolerable but still tasted like a lactose-themed student dorm nightmare, proving not all kitchen heroes wear capes.

Share the Story

(1 of 3)

Mockingbird News

@MockingbirdNews · now

Microwave mac and cheese still tastes like someone tried bathing pasta in milk while microwaving their hopes and dreams to death. Stick to the stove unless you like culinary regrets.

199/280 charactersReady to post