Hurricane Helene’s Mud Spa: FEMA’s Bureaucracy Edition

In North Carolina's wild west of weather (read: the Black Mountains), Brian and Susie Hill’s century-old dream farmhouse got a free mud makeover last September courtesy of Hurricane Helene, complete with a barn roof tossed in their yard (you don’t get that on HGTV!). The Hills, public school teachers and proud 30-year mortgage holders without flood insurance—because hey, their house wasn’t supposed to face the Big Bad 100-year flood—fought FEMA's labyrinthine aid maze for months. They scored just under FEMA’s $40,000 housing aid max. Meanwhile, down the hilly rabbit hole, folks faced withdrawn applications, birthday typos, and vanishing claims—because nothing says disaster relief like a bureaucratic scavenger hunt! Income mattered too: in cash-gilded Yancey and posh Haywood counties, the rich got 2-3 times more aid despite FEMA saying 'income schmincome.' And the Hills? Seven weeks of full pay for teaching allowed bureaucratic blitzkrieg maneuvering, turning time into the hottest flood survival luxury known to man. #FloodsThatFavorTheFortunate

Share the Story

(1 of 3)
Swipe to navigate

Source: Propublica | Published: 9/27/2025 | Author: by Jennifer Berry Hawes, ProPublica, and Ren Larson, The Assembly