America’s Best Steakhouses Awarded for Outsiders’ Weird Reasons, Not Steak
KEY POINTS
- •Musso & Frank in Los Angeles is praised for celebrity sightings and an indoor charcoal grill despite local bans.
- •Dai Due in Austin stands out for sourcing and hunting Texas meat, notably its dry-aged Texas wagyu rib-eye.
- •Annie’s Paramount in Washington D.C. has served its LGBTQ clientele with steak and strong martinis for nearly 80 years.
Forget flavor – Eater editors have crowned America’s top steakhouses for their niche quirks. Musso & Frank in L.A. is the only place where The Rolling Stones, Metallica, and Mad Men cast members all casually share martinis and racks of meat, thanks to an indoor charcoal grill loophole and a Marilyn Monroe booth. In Austin, Jesse Griffiths of Dai Due brings Texas-forever vibes by butchering and hunting his own cattle for dry-aged wagyu. Indianapolis’s St. Elmo hosted Ron Swanson’s fictional bachelor party with shrimp cocktails fierce enough to make Leslie Knope jealous, while Chicago’s Gibsons fuels the Viagra Triangle nightlife under the guise of steak. Tampa’s Bern’s racks a half-million wine bottles amidst Dracula-esque decor, and the Old Place in Malibu offers such convincing Old West time travel, you might dodge outlaw clams. Plus, Annie’s Paramount in D.C. is both a queer staple and martini haven for seven decades, proving some steaks come with a side of community spirit. We’re all terrible drivers of our own lives, but at least these restaurants made it to their destinations in bizarre style.
Share the Story
(1 of 3)America's best steakhouses are chosen for martinis with Mick Jagger, vampire wine cellars, and time-traveling clams. Somewhere Ron Swanson is reconsidering his life choices.
If your steakhouse doesn’t star The Rolling Stones or serve vintage wine in a Dracula ballroom, does it even steak?
Somewhere between Jack Daniel’s and Mad Men cocktails, America’s finest steakhouses forgot to just make good steak.
Source: Eater | Published: 4/21/2026 | Author: Ben Mesirow
More Articles in Entertainment
OpenAI CEO’s $27M Mansion Molotoved Amid AI Lab Soap Opera
Digital Nomad Trapped in Lisbon FOMO, Ends Up BFF Ghosted
Sydney Sweeney's $1M Flop, Trump-Approved Jeans & Bathwater Soap Fiasco
Anne Hathaway Drops 40, Finally Quits Living That 'Awkward Life'
Chef Rides Bike Then Insists Ancient Rum-Spiked Cheesecake Beats Avocado Toast
Sam Altman and Husband Show Up as Black Tuxedo Twinning Apps Malfunction
Gamer Goes on Vacation Just to Pray They Don’t Pick Super Meat Boy 3D
